BBP Rooftops - Summer 16 - page 13

13
H
ow the assets should be
divided can sometimes lead
to difficult discussions.
Solicitors can help by
providing advice on what
would be a fair financial settlement and
assist in discussions and negotiations.
Mediation can also be very useful.
Ultimately, if you cannot agree the couple
can seek resolution through making an
application to court or by using Family Law
Arbitration.
If you are able to reach agreement it is
always advisable to have that agreement
incorporated into a legally binding
agreement. If you are divorcing, a document
can be drawn up which is called a ‘Consent
Order’ and this is submitted to the court for
approval. If the Judge considers that the
agreement is fair to both parties they will
approve the order and the agreement will
become a court order which is capable of
enforcement if either party does not comply
with their obligations.
The effect of the order is usually that it is
final. There are limited circumstances where
a Court can be asked to vary the terms of a
Court order already made.
The matter can be returned to court,
however, if either party was not honest
about their financial circumstances at the
time of the hearing or during negotiations,
to the extent that the agreement reached and
the order made is not fair when the true
financial position is known. The other time
when a party may take a matter back to
court is if there is a significant change in
circumstance which would justify the
varying of the original Order.
The Court of Appeal in the case of
Critchell
v Critchell (2015)
upheld a decision to vary
the terms of a Consent Order. Ahusband
and wife had recently obtained a Consent
Order which provided that the former
matrimonial home, worth approximately
£190,000 would be transferred into the
wife’s sole name with a charge back to the
husband which equated to 45% of the equity
in the property. The impact of this was that
at some point in the future the wife would
have to either find the money to ‘buy out’
the husband or potentially sell the property
to pay him his share.
The court have to take into account a range
of factors including the respective incomes,
earning capacity, resources, length of
marriage, standard of living, conduct and
contributions when determining whether an
outcome is fair. As there were limited assets
available in this case, the court’s most
pressing concern was to ensure that the
parties’ needs would be met. The wife had a
‘need’ for the property to provide a home
and the husband had a ‘need’ to retain a
share to assist him in meeting his debts.
Within a month of the Consent Order, the
husband’s father suddenly passed away
and the husband received an inheritance of
£180,000.00. The wife applied to the Court to
vary the Consent Order on the basis that the
husband had received further capital. The
Court of Appeal allowed the wife’s appeal
on the basis that the husband’s needs had
altered due to the inheritance he had
received. The Court held that due to the
additional monies, the husband no longer
required the charge on the property and
accordingly the order was varied so that the
wife received the house absolutely.
It is extremely difficult to re-open a final
court order. It has to be right that once a
court has approved an order which says that
it is in full and final satisfaction of a couples
claims against each other, that the parties
can consider that it is the end of the matter.
There are, however, a few rare cases where
this does happen, so this recent case serves
as a reminder that even a final order may
not be final if either party face an
unexpected and significant change in
financial circumstances shortly after the
order is made.
n
Holmes &Hills Solicitors are a regional
law firmwith five offices across Essex and
Suffolk, these being located in Sudbury,
Halstead, Braintree, Coggeshall and Tiptree.
Tel: 01787 275275
Dividing assets when
separating from a partner
1...,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12 14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,...76
Powered by FlippingBook